The short answer

Give each set of parents one anchor day this year, swap next year, and cover the other side with a scheduled video call and a visit within a few days. Put the plan on one page and share it with both sides on the same day, before anyone books travel.

Hold a short phone or video meeting with your partner and any siblings to build the schedule and see what each person can take on. Ask each parent ahead of time what they would like most, then decide on your top priorities and save the rest for another visit.

Write the result on paper or in the family decision worksheet, so there is one version everyone can point to.

A worked schedule for two households

An illustrative example: You and your partner each have parents who want you for the holidays. The two sets live about four hours apart by car, and your home is roughly in between, two hours from each. Here is what you might write in the family decision worksheet.

Day Where you spend it Who travels How the other side is covered
Thanksgiving Day Your parents' home You and your partner drive two hours Video call with your partner's parents before dinner, then lunch with them the Saturday after
Christmas Eve and Christmas Day Your partner's parents' home You drive two hours and stay one night Video call with your parents on Christmas morning, then a visit on December 27
New Year's Day Your own home No one One group video call with both sets at a time everyone agreed on

Next year the two sets swap: Thanksgiving with your partner's parents, Christmas with yours. Each side gets one anchor day, a call and a visit, and the table names who drives so nobody has to assume.

The cells to fill in on your own version are the day, the place, who travels, and what covers the other side. If you're the only one coordinating, that is the whole job. If siblings live near one set of parents, hand them that set's row. If your two sets are divorced parents, the same table works with one row per household.

If your parents live much farther apart than four hours, or you'd need to fly, drop the second visit and let one longer trip carry each side: a few days around Thanksgiving with one set, a few days around Christmas with the other, and a call on the day you're away. If both sets live in the same town, keep the table and shorten the "who travels" column to the drive between houses.

Explaining it to both families

Tell both sets the same thing in the same words, on the same day, so neither hears the plan second-hand. Start with what each side gets: their anchor day, the call and the visit. A starting script:

We want to see both of you this season, so we've made a plan for this year and next. This year we're with you for Thanksgiving, and with [the other side] for Christmas. We'll video call you on Christmas morning and come see you on the 27th. Next year it flips. What matters most to you about the day, so we can build it in?

If one side asks for a bigger share, offer a longer call or a weekend visit in January instead of more of the same day.

The objection you're most likely to hear is "But we always have Christmas." Let them finish, then name what the tradition means to them before you repeat the plan:

Christmas with you has meant so much for so many years, and we want to keep it. We can't be in two places on one day, so this year it's [the other side]'s turn, and next year Christmas is yours. We'll call first thing Christmas morning and be there on the 27th. Is there one part of your Christmas, like the tree or the big meal, that we could do with you that day?

Then stop. Don't reopen the whole plan on the spot. If they're still upset, say you'll talk again after the weekend and keep the schedule as written. Update the other side only when something truly changes, so neither set hears a different plan.

If travel is hard for either set, visiting them at home gives you a smaller gathering in familiar surroundings, which can mean more meaningful time together. Feeling guilty about the day you'll miss is normal and understandable.

When someone is unwell or can't travel

Move the day to that parent's home, shorten it, and keep the call. The rest of the schedule can stay as written, and the other side still gets their call and visit. For anything about a parent's health, check with their usual doctor.

Plan a second quick call in early December to confirm the schedule still holds. The Family Caregiver Alliance recommends calling a family meeting early and then again as often as you need.

Sources used for this answer

Spotted a mistake or a source we should look at? Tell us.

What to do next